How we check
Nostranope collects big, specific claims and predictions by public figures, and puts each one next to what actually happened. The rules below decide what goes on the site.
What gets in
- Their own words, verbatim. Every quote comes from the person's own video or audio on an official channel, their own post, or an official word-for-word transcript (government, company or the show's own). A news report quoting them helps us find the original, but is never enough on its own.
- Specific and checkable. The claim names something that can be checked, usually with a date: a number, an event, a deadline.
- Settled. The deadline has passed, or the outcome is known, and there is published, dated evidence of it. Claims whose deadline is still ahead go on the watchlist.
- Bold. Big enough that saying it got attention.
- Fair in context. We read what came before and after. We leave out hedged guesses ("maybe", "my guess is"), clear jokes, ranges and opinions. Caveats the person gave are shown in a "Fair context" box on the entry.
We don't include private individuals, children, or anything about a person's health or private life. Viral "quotes" we can't trace to the person are left out.
Verdicts
- Didn't happen: The deadline passed and it has not happened.
- Proved false: What they said was shown to be wrong by the evidence.
- Happened late: It happened, but well after the date they gave.
- Partly: Part of the claim held; the rest did not.
- Watchlist: The deadline is still ahead. We will check it when it passes.
We describe what was said and what happened. We don't judge anyone's motives or character.
Each person's page lists bold claims that didn't hold up. It isn't a full record of everything they've said or got right.
Evidence on every entry
- The exact quote, the date and where it was said, with a link to the original (at the right second for video) and an archived copy in case the original disappears.
- Dated sources for the outcome: official statistics, company filings, results, market data.
- Two separate checks of the quote against the source before it goes up, and the date it was last checked.
Video clips
Clips are embedded from the original upload and start at the moment the claim was made. Nothing loads from YouTube until you press play, and then it loads from youtube-nocookie.com. We don't copy or re-host anyone's video.
Mistakes
If something here is wrong, tell us. We take an entry down while we re-check it, then fix it or remove it, and list the change on the corrections page.